If you are having thoughts of suicide, call or text 988 to reach the Suicide & Crisis Lifeline. In an emergency, call 911.
You’re trying to get your toddler to eat dinner when your mother says, “You’re too soft on her.” Your father-in-law tells your son to “toughen up.” An aunt you barely know swoops in for a kiss, and when your daughter pulls away, someone says, “Don’t be rude, give Auntie a hug. She came all this way.”
Holiday gatherings put your parenting on display in front of the people who raised you. This article covers two common challenges: handling unwanted parenting advice and protecting your children’s right to say no to hugs and kisses.
Section 1: Unsolicited parenting advice
Why family offers it
Most unsolicited advice comes from a good place, even when it doesn’t feel that way. Grandparents and relatives may:
- Want to feel useful or connected to the grandkids
- Worry about the child, or about you
- Parent the way they were parented, which may be very different from current guidance
- Feel judged when you do things differently, as if your choices criticize theirs
Why it stings
Unsolicited advice from your own parent can land as criticism, even when it’s not meant that way. If you grew up feeling never good enough, comments about your parenting can reopen that old wound. (See Article 8.) It can also pull you back into an old family role. (See Article 7.)
You’re the parent now
Your children, your rules. You can respect your parents’ experience and still make different choices. A Los Angeles psychologist suggests something like this: “You raised me to take parenting seriously, and I do. I’d like you to honor that, too” (Austrew, 2025).
Sort the advice: safety vs. preference
Not every comment needs a response. Ask yourself whether the issue is about your child’s safety or core values, or just a difference in style.
- Safety and values: car seats, safe sleep, allergies, screen-time rules you care about, discipline methods, food restrictions, body boundaries. Hold firm.
- Style: bedtime being 30 minutes late, an extra cookie at Grandma’s, a different way of folding laundry. Consider letting it go, especially for a short visit.
Picking your battles saves your energy for what matters.
Scripts for unwanted advice
Light and quick
- “Thanks, we’ve got it handled.”
- “Interesting. We’re trying something different.”
- “That worked for you. This is what works for us.”
Clear and kind
- “I know you care about him. I need you to trust me on this one.”
- “I’d rather not get parenting advice today unless I ask for it.”
- “We’ve talked to our pediatrician, and this is the plan we’re following.”
When it continues
- “I’ve already decided. I’m not going to discuss it anymore.”
- “Please don’t correct my kids in front of me. If you have a concern, talk to me privately.”
- “If this keeps coming up, we’ll need to take a break and head out.”
Tips for making it stick
- Get on the same page with your partner first. Agree on your non-negotiables before the gathering.
- Each partner handles their own family. It usually goes better when your mother hears it from you, and your partner’s mother hears it from your partner. (Article 15 covers being caught between your partner and your family.)
- Talk before, not during. If you know a topic will come up, address it ahead of time, by phone or in private, not in front of the kids at the dinner table.
- Don’t undermine each other in front of the children. Ask relatives to bring concerns to you privately, and do the same yourself.
- Set clear rules if they’re babysitting. If grandparents care for your kids, ask them to follow your rules on safety, food, and discipline. Write them down if it helps.
- Acknowledge the good intentions. Experts suggest thanking grandparents for their care, and recognizing that they mean well, before you set a limit (Austrew, 2025). “I know you love them so much” can soften almost any limit. (Article 20 has more on setting boundaries, and Article 21 has coping skills for the season.)
Section 2: Your child doesn’t owe anyone a hug
Why this matters
Many of us grew up being told to kiss Grandpa or hug the relative we hadn’t seen in a year, whether we wanted to or not. The intention was good: to show respect and affection.
Many child-development and abuse-prevention groups now encourage parents not to force physical affection. A widely shared 2017 Girl Scouts message, “She doesn’t owe anyone a hug. Not even at the holidays,” warned that making kids hug someone because that person gave a gift or hasn’t seen them in a while can confuse children about consent later in life (Kindelan, 2017). The message was written about girls, but it's true for boys too.
Teaching children that they get a say over their own bodies helps them:
- Learn that “no” is a real choice, and that their “no” will be respected
- Feel more confident speaking up if someone makes them uncomfortable
- Trust their own instincts and feelings
- Understand that affection should be freely given, not owed
Abuse-prevention advocates point out that adults hold a lot of authority in children’s lives, and that kids need to know body safety rules apply even with grown-ups they know (Zero Abuse Project, n.d.).
Saying no isn’t the same as being rude
Respecting your child’s body doesn’t mean letting them ignore people. The Girl Scouts message was clear that skipping a hug isn’t permission to be rude, and there are many other ways to show love and thanks (“Girl Scouts Warn Parents,” n.d.).
Give your child options:
- A wave or a smile
- A high five or fist bump
- Blowing a kiss
- Saying “Hi, Grandma!” or “Thank you for the present”
- Drawing a picture or making a card
Let your child choose. Many kids warm up on their own with a little time.
Prepare your child ahead of time
Before the gathering, talk with your child in simple words:
- “Lots of people will be excited to see you. You get to choose how you say hello.”
- “If you don’t want a hug, you can give a high five or wave instead.”
- “If someone doesn’t listen when you say no, come find me. You won’t be in trouble.”
Practice with a quick role-play. Kids feel more confident when they’ve tried the words before.
Explain your child’s boundaries to family
It often works best to tell relatives before the gathering, so no one is caught off guard.
- “We’re teaching the kids that they get to choose how they show affection. If they don’t want to hug, please don’t push it. A high five works great.”
- “It’s not about you. We’re helping them learn that their body belongs to them.”
- “Please ask before hugging or picking them up. If they say no, just let it go.”
The Zero Abuse Project suggests telling the adults in your child’s life that you expect your child’s boundaries to be respected, and teaching them to ask instead of demand (Zero Abuse Project, n.d.).
In the moment
When a relative pressures your child, step in calmly and keep it light:
- “She’s not feeling huggy right now. Want a high five, sweetie?”
- “He gets to decide. Let’s give him some time to warm up.”
- “We don’t make the kids hug. Wave hi to Uncle Joe!”
If someone pushes with guilt (“You’re hurting Grandma’s feelings!”), protect your child from the guilt:
- To your child: “You didn’t do anything wrong.”
- To the relative, privately if possible: “I know it stings. Give them time. They may warm up on their own. Please don’t make them feel guilty.”
Other body boundaries to watch
- Tickling. When a child says stop, stop, even if they’re laughing.
- Comments about bodies or weight. “She’s getting chubby” or “He needs to eat more” can stick with kids for years.
- Food pressure. “Clean your plate” or “Just one more bite for Grandma.” These can teach kids to ignore their own hunger and fullness cues.
- Teasing that crosses a line. Laughing at a child who is upset, or mocking them for being shy.
Trust your child, and your gut
If your child strongly avoids a certain adult, don’t push. Gently ask how they feel about that person, and listen. If someone in the family has harmed children, or you have concerns about a person’s behavior, your child’s safety comes before anyone’s feelings. (See Article 12.) If you suspect a child is being abused, call the Childhelp National Child Abuse Hotline at 1-800-422-4453.
Support for parents
Standing up to your own parents can feel like being a kid again (see Article 6). At Psychiatric Alternatives and Wellness Center (PAWC), our therapists help parents set boundaries with extended family, manage guilt, and build the confidence to parent in line with your values.
We accept many insurance plans, which can make care more affordable than you might expect. Contact PAWC today to schedule your first appointment. You can respect your family and still protect your children.
References
Austrew, A. (2025, December 15). 5 healthy boundaries for grandparents and how to discuss them early. Care.com. https://www.care.com/c/?p=47653
Girl Scouts warn parents not to force their daughters to hug anyone during holiday season. (n.d.). Yahoo. https://www.yahoo.com/lifestyle/girl-scouts-warn-parents-not-015013747.html
Kindelan, K. (2017, November 20). Girl Scouts warn parents about forcing kids to hug relatives for the holidays. Good Morning America. https://www.goodmorningamerica.com/news/story/girl-scouts-force-kids-hug-relatives-holiday-season-51275036
Zero Abuse Project. (n.d.). Faculty response to the Girl Scouts of America blog post “Reminder: She doesn’t owe anyone a hug. Not even at the holidays”. https://zeroabuseproject.org/faculty-response-to-the-the-girl-scouts-of-america-blog-post-reminder-she-doesnt-owe-anyone-a-hug-not-even-at-the-holidays/