If you are having thoughts of suicide, call or text 988 to reach the Suicide & Crisis Lifeline. In an emergency, call 911.
Your mom makes little digs about your partner all through dinner. Your partner dreads every visit and asks why you never stand up for them. Your siblings text you complaints, and your partner vents to you on the drive home. You spend the whole holiday translating, smoothing things over, and trying to keep everyone happy. By the end of the day, you feel exhausted and guilty, and somehow everyone is upset with you.
If this sounds familiar, you’re not alone. Being caught between the people you love is one of the most stressful family situations there is, and the holidays turn up the pressure.
Why this hurts so much
Research shows that family and friends’ opinions of our relationships matter more than we like to admit. Relationship researchers have found that feeling approved of by your family and friends was linked to more love, satisfaction, and commitment in your relationship (UC Davis, n.d.-b). Disapproval, on the other hand, has been linked to lower satisfaction and a higher risk of breakups (In-Mind, n.d.).
Family disapproval can also feel personal. Researchers note it can make people feel that they are being judged, not just their relationship (Society for Personality and Social Psychology [SPSP], n.d.). That’s especially true for people in same-sex or interracial relationships, or relationships that cross cultural or religious lines. (Article 16 covers coming home as LGBTQ+.)
Why you end up in the middle
Family therapists call this pattern triangulation: when two people in conflict route their feelings through a third person instead of dealing with each other directly. You become the messenger, the referee, and the shock absorber.
Many people who end up in the middle were also peacemakers or caretakers growing up. (See Article 7 on family roles.) Keeping everyone happy feels familiar, even when it’s wearing you down.
Signs you’re stuck in the middle
- You pass messages between your partner and your family
- You hide or soften what each side says about the other
- You feel responsible for how everyone feels during visits
- You defend your partner to your family, then defend your family to your partner
- You dread the holidays because of the tension, not the event itself
- You feel like no one is ever fully on your side
First, get honest about the disapproval
Not all family concerns are the same. Before deciding how to respond, it helps to ask what the disapproval is really about.
- Differences in style or values. Your partner is quieter, louder, from a different background, religion, or class, or simply not who your family pictured. These are usually about your family’s expectations, not your partner’s character.
- Bias or prejudice. Disapproval rooted in race, ethnicity, religion, sexual orientation, gender identity, or disability says more about your family than your partner. You don’t have to accept it.
- Control. Some family members struggle to let go of their adult children, or need to be at the center. Research has even found that family members with strong narcissistic traits are more likely to interfere in relationships they dislike (Collisson, 2022). (See Article 9.)
- Real concerns. Sometimes family sees something worth listening to. If they’re worried about how your partner treats you, take a moment to reflect honestly. Researchers note that our social networks are sometimes better at spotting what’s good for us than we are (UC Davis, n.d.-a). Warning signs include a partner who:
- Controls your money, your phone, or who you see
- Isolates you from family and friends
- Puts you down
- Makes you feel afraid
- Hurts you physically
If any of this sounds familiar, you deserve support. The National Domestic Violence Hotline (1-800-799-7233) is free and confidential.
If you’re in a committed relationship: you’re a team
A Cornell study of hundreds of older Americans looking back on their marriages found a consistent piece of advice: when there’s conflict between your spouse and your family, support your spouse. Some of the most bitter marital disputes came from one partner failing to back the other up (Pillemer, 2016).
Supporting your partner doesn’t mean cutting off your family. It means your partner can trust that you won’t side against them or leave them alone to take the hits.
How to step out of the middle
A few shifts can take you out of the referee role:
- Stop being the messenger. You don’t have to relay complaints in either direction. “If you have a concern about her, please bring it to me directly. I’m not going to pass messages back and forth.”
- Handle your own family. It usually works best when you set limits with your family, and your partner sets limits with theirs. You’re the one with the history and the standing.
- Don’t vent about your partner to your family. Family tends to remember the complaint long after you and your partner have made up.
- Get on the same page first. Before a holiday visit, agree with your partner on how long you’ll stay, what topics are off-limits, and a signal for when one of you needs a break.
- Validate both sides, but stand by your values. You can say to your mom, “I know you love me and want the best for me,” and also, “I’ve chosen him, and I need you to treat him with respect.”
- Set clear limits on disrespect. You can’t force your family to like your partner. You can expect them to be polite.
- Don’t make your partner carry it alone. If your partner is the target of comments, step in. Your silence can feel like agreement.
Scripts for your family
- “I know you have concerns. I’ve heard them. I’ve made my decision.”
- “You don’t have to love him, but I need you to be kind to him.”
- “If there are more comments like that today, we’re going to leave.”
- “I’m not going to talk about her when she’s not here. If you have something to say, talk to me about us.”
- “I love you, and I love my partner. I’m not going to choose between you, and I’m not going to let either of you be treated badly.”
Scripts for your partner
- “I hear you. That comment wasn’t okay.”
- “I’m on your side. I want us to handle my family together.”
- “What would help you feel more comfortable at the visit?”
- “I can’t make them change, but I can set limits and leave if it gets bad.”
Holiday survival tips
- Shorter visits. A few good hours beats a tense weekend.
- Stay somewhere else. A hotel gives you both space to recharge.
- Drive separately if needed, so either of you can leave.
- Plan time for just the two of you before and after.
- Split holidays if needed, or create your own traditions as a couple.
- Debrief kindly afterward. Talk about what went well and what to change next time, without blaming each other.
When nothing changes
Sometimes, despite your best efforts, family members won’t accept your partner. You may need to see them less or visit without your partner. These are painful decisions, and they’re yours to make. If the conflict is causing ongoing stress in your relationship, couples therapy can help you and your partner build a united approach.
Support for you, or for both of you
Being the bridge between people you love is exhausting, and you’re allowed to put the job down. At Psychiatric Alternatives and Wellness Center (PAWC), our therapists help individuals and couples manage family conflict, set limits with relatives, and step out of the peacekeeper role. Therapy can also help you sort through mixed feelings, especially when you’re not sure whose concerns to trust.
We accept many insurance plans, which can make care more affordable than you might expect. Contact PAWC today to schedule your first appointment. You don’t have to keep holding everyone together on your own.
References
Collisson, B. (2022, June). Why some people try to sabotage others’ relationships. Psychology Today. https://psychologytoday.com/sg/blog/dating-toxic-or-tender/202206/why-some-people-try-sabotage-others-relationships
In-Mind. (n.d.). Does parental disapproval lead to love or dissolution? The Romeo and Juliet effect vs. the social network effect. https://in-mind.org/node/192
Pillemer, K. (2016, October 17). Three tips for making the best of in-law relationships. Cornell Legacy Project. https://legacyproject.human.cornell.edu/2016/10/17/three-tips-for-making-the-best-of-in-law-relationships
Society for Personality and Social Psychology. (n.d.). When your friends and family disapprove of your romantic partner. Character & Context. https://spsp.org/news-center/character-context-blog/when-your-friends-and-family-disapprove-your-romantic-partner
UC Davis. (n.d.-a). Relationships shaped by family, friends. https://www.ucdavis.edu/news/relationships-shaped-family-friends-0
UC Davis. (n.d.-b). Support of family, friends strong influence on relationships. https://ucdavis.edu/news/support-family-friends-strong-influence-relationships